📖 ZKIZ Archives


要改數呢... 中產管數男

http://www.menwhenmiddle.com/2011/02/blog-post_17.html

以下是某天管數男與某逼科manager既對話。要有audit experience先睇得明

M = Audit manager
C = 我管數男

M:我發現你地有條 sub-group level 既 interco sales and purchase 未 eliminate 喎...

C:我知,但舊年都冇 eliminate 啦,而且條數應該唔大,唔好搞咁多野啦...

M:唔係呢,要做呢...

C:條數幾大呀?

M:3,000萬到啦

C:下?我地group turnover有成400億喎,3,000萬好immaterial者,1%都唔到...(開始不耐煩地)

M:唔係呢要改呢...(繼續死纏爛打)

C:幫你諗埋勒,因為你地要出sub-consol level既audit report,就算以sub-group level既materiality level黎睇,個sub-group turnover都有成25億,3,000萬好immaterial者,約1.2%左右,都仲係好細,又影響個GP ratio都唔夠0.5%上落,都好少者... (真係想講粗口)

M:唔係呢,個數銀碼大嘛...(再繼續死纏爛打)

C:3,000萬都話大? (真係火都黎)

M:...... (唔出聲)

C:唔好講group level既400億,就算係25億,當 eliminate 左3,000萬呢條數後,你覺得24.7億同25億對個users of financial statements來講有咩分別?會唔會mislead個users?

M:...... (唔出聲,冇得反駁)

C:總之唔改就唔改,唔eliminate... (語氣帶點燥意)

M:唔係呢,老闆(即partner)要改呀...

C:等我同佢解釋下 (其實真想話:叫佢call我等我educate下佢)

M:咁又唔駛,等我試下同老闆解釋下,應該冇問題既...

C:...... (頂!真係&%^%^&%XYZ,自己搞得掂個老闆就唔好煩個client啦)

後記:我個人覺得,煩少D client,對client來講都係value added既service。

PermaLink: https://articles.zkiz.com/?id=22419

Next Page

ZKIZ Archives @ 2019